Book your acquisition audit

Customer acquisition

Pay for performance marketing: what counts as a result

Your ad spend goes to Google and Meta under every model. The agency's fee follows whatever the contract calls a result

A stainless-steel turnstile in an empty office lobby in morning light, with large windows behind

Pay for performance marketing means an agency earns all or part of its fee from a result you agree in advance, such as a qualified lead, a booked appointment or a sale, instead of from hours or a flat retainer. Your ad spend still goes to Google and Meta either way.

You'll hear the phrase used for 4 different deals and only one of them is how an agency gets paid. 2 lines in the contract decide what you pay for: what counts as a result and who holds the keys to the ad accounts when the work ends.

We're Leadflix, an agency in Malmö, Sweden and our own model is results-⁠based, so put the 6 questions further down to us too.

Pay for performance marketing means 4 different deals

In each of the 4, your money goes somewhere different. You'll also hear it called performance-based, results-⁠based or commission-⁠based marketing.

The dealWho you pay and for what
The ad platform's pricingGoogle or Meta, per click, impression or action
AffiliateA publisher, paid a commission for an agreed action such as a sale
Agency pay on resultsThe agency, per result written into the contract, alone or on top of a fixed fee
Pay-per-ranking SEOAn SEO firm, for a page-⁠one position on Google

The first row is what the platform charges. Google Ads charges per click with cost-per-click bidding (Google Ads Help) and Meta usually charges per impression (Meta Business Help Center). You pay that in a month with no results too and a fee set as a percentage of ad spend grows as you spend more, whatever the spend brings back.

What counts as a qualified lead and where the result should sit

Put the result at the last step the agency itself controls. Anything earlier it can fill with cheap volume and anything later is down to you:

  1. Lead: a form someone filled in.
  2. Qualified lead: a form that meets criteria you wrote down, such as the right service, the right area and a phone number that connects.
  3. Booked appointment: a consultation or meeting in your calendar.
  4. Kept appointment: the customer turns up.
  5. Sale: the customer says yes.

An agency that only runs ads lets go at the form, while one that also replies, qualifies and books carries on to the visit.

In a 2021 report for Sweden's National Agency for Public Procurement, economist Mats Bergman sums up the research on pay for performance: people paid on what's measured put their effort there. The measure should therefore be both important and hard to game. No bonus should pay out for events the provider doesn't control (Report 2021:2, pages 44 and 45, in Swedish).

The form is the easiest step to inflate. In Meta Ads Manager the default instant form is More volume, built to generate more leads. Higher intent adds a review screen meant to stop submissions from people who aren't very interested Meta Business Help Center. On a pay-per-lead contract, the agency earns most from the default.

Worked example, not client figures: 100 leads, 40 book and 30 turn up. Pay per lead and you pay for 100 results, per booking for 40 and per kept appointment for 30. You can't compare a price per result until you know which step it counts. Work out your cost per step with our cost per lead guide.

Worked example in 3 steps: per lead 100 results, per booking 40 results, per kept visit 30 results
Worked example, not client figures: 100 leads, 40 book and 30 turn up. The same month is 100, 40 or 30 results, depending on the step the contract counts.

Clinics: the result is the patient at the consultation

For dental clinics and aesthetic clinics, an agency that books for you stops at the door, when the patient comes in for the consultation. We draw the line there: the consultation is the result. Whether the patient says yes is up to your team and how they sell.

Ours is results-⁠based for that reason, weighted to what a booked appointment is worth to you. Here's how it looks at one of the dental clinics we do this for:

43

patients a month on average, 80% of them came in for implants Gamla Staden Tandvård, dental clinic, Sweden

For what each pricing model rewards in a clinic, see what a booked appointment service should include.

Home improvement: the result is the site visit

For a roofing, building or energy company, the visit to the homeowner is the last step an agency can influence. You decide on site how many visits turn into signed jobs.

230 SEK

per qualified lead (about $23) and 55% of leads reach a booking Nordiska Takbehandlingar, roof treatment, Sweden

Pay per lead and you also pay for the leads that never reach a booking. Öbo Hus runs on our system with a $190k average sale: 60 scheduled appointments every month.

How marketing agencies charge and when a fixed fee wins

Sweden's advertisers' and media agencies' associations list 5 ways to pay a media agency (their joint recommendation, in Swedish). The 5 are a fixed monthly fee, a volume-⁠based fee, hourly pay, performance-based pay and a combination of those.

In the US, the ANA's 2022 survey of 101 client-⁠side marketers found 82% using fee-⁠based compensation, up from 68% in 2016. Performance incentives on top of fees fell to 41%, from 61% in 2013 (ANA, December 2022).

Pay for performance fits when you can count the result in your calendar. A new website, a brand or an audit has no such result. The Swedish recommendation also says an advertiser shouldn't pay a media auditor on results, since the auditor has to stay objective. Bergman goes further in the procurement report: sometimes no incentive beats one that covers only part of what you want (section 14.3).

In Google Ads, a user with Admin access can always unlink the agency's manager account, even when the agency created the account and became its owner (Google Ads Help, access levels). Make sure you have such a user yourself.

Then check who pays. If the account is on monthly invoicing and the agency's manager account is the paying one, the ads stop serving when you unlink it, until you set up billing again. The campaign history stays, but the agency's shared remarketing lists and conversion tag stop working for the account (Google Ads Help on unlinking).

At Meta, an agency can advertise on your behalf from its own business portfolio. Your business then can't see that ad account unless the agency grants you permission (Meta Business Help Center).

With us, the ad accounts and the CRM with your customer conversations belong to you and they stay yours if you leave. Tor Dental reached 50 implant consultations a month, then a 2nd clinic, then an in-⁠house marketing team we trained, with no dip in the handover.

Notice periods: what you still pay after you quit

In Sweden, where we're based, the agencies' standard terms give 3 months' notice on open-⁠ended agreements. Any agreed retainer is still payable during the notice period unless you agree otherwise (KOMM and Sveriges Annonsörer, General Terms 2021, clause 16.3, in Swedish). The same terms define "result" as what the agency delivers, such as a strategy, a concept or a web solution (clause 2.4). If the result you pay for is a booked appointment, write that into your contract.

Between businesses, Swedish law sets no maximum. Section 36 of the Contracts Act lets a court adjust or set aside an unreasonable term (riksdagen.se, in Swedish). The court gives special regard to protecting a consumer or any other party in a weaker position, but the section names no number of months.

Outside Sweden no trade-⁠wide default applies: you pay what the contract says, so get question 6 answered in writing.

Ours has no lock-⁠in. Cancel any time.

6 questions to ask before you sign a pay for performance deal

Get the answers in writing:

  1. What counts as a result, word for word and at which step?
  2. Where is the result counted: in the ad platform, in the agency's system or in my calendar?
  3. Which results get rejected, such as duplicates and wrong numbers and within how many days?
  4. What do I pay in a month with no results and in a month with twice as many?
  5. Whose name is on the ad accounts and the CRM, who pays the platform and what happens to them the day we part?
  6. How long is the notice period and what do I pay during it?

For US dentists, the ADA's code of ethics adds a rule on how the fee is computed. A dentist who pays a marketing vendor a set share of the fees collected from patients is fee splitting, which the code prohibits (opinion 4.E.1). A dentist may pay for advertising but generally not for the referral of a patient (opinion 5.F.4). State rules can add more (ADA Code of Ethics, revised to March 2023). Check any US dental deal priced per patient against both.

Question 2 matters because Meta counts a conversion within 1 or 7 days of a click, or 1 day of an impression. Meta also says to judge performance in your own analytics if you use them (Meta Business Help Center).

Ask us the same 6.

This is how we run it for dental clinics, aesthetic clinics and home improvement companies.

40,000+

sales appointments, for the businesses we do this for Leadflix

Straight answers to common questions

What is a pay for performance marketing agency?

It's an agency that earns all or part of its fee per agreed result, such as a qualified lead or a booked appointment, rather than per hour or per month. The ad spend stays separate. Before you compare prices, ask which step of the funnel it counts as the result.

How much does a pay for performance marketing agency cost?

The price per result depends on which step the contract counts, so ask that first and your ad spend goes to Google and Meta on top of the agency's fee. At Leadflix: no price list, because the structure changes with the business. What's fixed: results-⁠based, weighted to what a booked appointment is worth to you, no lock-⁠in. You get a straight number on the call, before you commit to anything.

Is pay for performance the same as pay per click?

No. Pay per click is how Google charges you for each click on an ad. Pay for performance is how you pay the agency and the two run side by side: Google bills per click while the agency bills per booked appointment.

What are the downsides of pay for performance?

The agency works toward whatever the contract counts. Leave the result vague and you pay for cheap volume and agree to a cut of revenue and you pay the agency for your team's selling. In the ANA's 2022 survey, most marketers said they didn't know whether performance incentives improved their agency's work.

What happens to my ad account when I switch agencies?

In Google Ads, a user with Admin access on your account can always unlink the agency's manager account. If the agency pays the invoice, move billing first or the ads stop. Under Sweden's standard agency terms, the agency also hands over all material you own.

Can a marketing agency guarantee results?

No agency controls what Google and Meta deliver for your budget. Google says nobody can guarantee a top ranking in its search results and adds that you're responsible for what the companies you hire do. A contract can fix the price per result and what counts as one.

Back to top

Oscar Cruz, founder of Leadflix

Author

Oscar Cruz

Founder, Leadflix

Leadflix started when our founder, Oscar Cruz, saw that most gyms and trainers were terrible at marketing and started fixing it. Clinics and home improvement came next, where 1 new customer is worth enough that the math changes: fill the calendar and the business grows. 80+ businesses, $7M in client revenue and 40,000+ sales appointments later, that is still the whole job.

Articles by Oscar
Book your acquisition audit

What you'll get on the call

A free 30-minute call. You'll leave knowing what to do next, whether or not we work together

  1. 01
    A review of what you're running nowYour spend, your ads, how leads are handled, and what your numbers do and don't tell you.
  2. 02
    Your single biggest constraintThe one thing holding back new customers, and exactly how we'd fix it.
  3. 03
    A clear plan, either wayYou'll leave knowing what to do next, whether or not you work with us.

You'll get a calendar invite and a video call link as soon as you book.

5.0 on Google across 26 reviews, from the businesses we run this for.

The calendar didn't load.

Book directly on Cal.com

Or call Oscar: +46 73-181 81 82